Individuals who sincerely identify themselves as transgender for the first time during 2024 will resolve to YES. Identifying as nonbinary will also count as YES, assuming this comes with different pronouns, hormone replacement, name change, or significant change in clothing or makeup style.
"None listed here" will resolve to YES if none of the other legitimate choices resolve to YES. Names added retroactively, after the person already came out, will be ignored for determining this.
1,000
3.00@RanaG it wasn't an explicit no, it was an "I'm on HRT and gender fluid but I don't like labels" which I think qualifies as a sub category of trans, but we could hold an opinion poll once they're affordable again to decide it if you want
Gender fluid is very close to cross dressing which doesn't constitute a change to the status quo.
Being transgender is defined as transitioning to and identifying as the opposite sex. Finn had never and still doesn't identify as a woman.
The question includes nonbinary to qualify a YES but Finn neither describes himself as full time nonbinary nor does he explicitly reject identifying as a man.
@RanaG to me trans is a blanket term for any gender identity other than cis, and gender fluid means frequently changing gender identity, whereas cross-dressing is simply the outfit change with zero identity change
@RanaG this reminds me of the existential comic on prescriptive vs descriptive linguists
@RanaG My interpretation is that he identifies as non-binary enough to qualify for this market (especially combined with the HRT and being open to any pronoun), even if he rejects the "trans" label itself.