I've been chatting with @BTE about their plan to found a competitor to Manifold. The core plan is a little differerent from the direction Manifold has gone, and seems like it could go very well or completely fail. I've been asked not to share the details.
Resolves subjectivly based on whether it overall seems to have worked out. (Resolves N/A if it's not attempted.) I won't bet.
You can learn more here: https://manifold.markets/jack/will-socialpredict-be-run-by-two-pu
BTE got banned for abusing a mana-printing exploit.
Here is a (hopefully) more publicly verifiable market on the same topic. https://manifold.markets/jack/will-socialpredict-be-run-by-two-pu
@IsaacKing I didn't realize the secret plan working was the same thing as the site being successful but if that's the case then yeah this is very high.
@Joshua It's possible for this market to resolve YES while that one resolves NO; BTE's plan could work well enough to get his site to be somewhat popular, but it doesn't quite surpass Manifold. Or it gets super popular really quickly but then dies away before 2 years have passed.
But it's not a 50 percentage point difference.
Now that the website is up, the attempt is made and this will not resolve NA. So far, I don't see a plan that is worth keeping secret.
@marktwse maybe the secret plan is to get attention by having us all speculate about what his secret plan is
@ClubmasterTransparent Not the best comparison. Restaurants are the most likely businesses to fail. Everyone wants to open a restaurant. Turns out the market is not that large. Prediction markets are quite the opposite. Only a small fraction of the potential market space is captured.
@Shump good points. But there's huge need for scale just getting a prediction market off the ground. Appears to be many underrepresented groups of potential bettors here even if we limit the universe to reasonably intelligent and well-intentioned people. There are only so many AI "enthusiasts", LW community and millennials/Zennials in the world.