Will a non-human primate be the first species we uplift?
15
Ṁ316
2041
50%
chance

Resolution details will be the same as discussed on this market:

See also discussion there about my take on relative pros and cons of Koi vs Octopuses vs Mammals.

Note: Subsidized with intent to provoke betting and discussion.

Get Ṁ1,000 play money
Sort by:
predicts YES

If you add this to the monke group, you can make Levi give you 100 free mana.

Not sure why this is lower than 50%. If we ever uplift any species, I would expect it to almost certainly be another primate. Uplifting a non-primate species means trying to give human-level intelligence to something that's totally different from humans. You wouldn't be able to just give them a brain structured like a human's and expect it to work.

@JosephNoonan I think it makes more sense to give human-level intelligence to something that's not a primate, because we already have humans. Also, there are lots of non-primate mammals available.

predicts YES

@MartinRandall I don't really get the first sentence, unless what you meant to say was "not similar to humans". I agree that that would make the most sense as an eventual goal, but I don't think we would jump from being unable to uplift anything at all to uplifting something that's very different from a human. Primates seem like the obvious first step.

predicts NO

@JosephNoonan A month later and I can edit my post. Sorry for the typo.

predicts YES

@MartinRandall Now there's a (minor) typo in this comment as well