When one of these Youtube personalities publicly comes around and seriously identifies as a Christian before 2025, that option will resolve YES. All those who remain non-Christian on Jan 1. 2025 resolve NO.
Comment if there are other atheist Youtubers you want to see on this list!
The only youtube atheists who become Christians are the conservative ones (the ones who pivoted to the gamergate/anti-SJW stuff). Some of them converted to Christianity because they agreed with the Christian right's talking points about religion being necessary for civilization (or just to appeal to a conservative audience, depending on how cynical you are about it). None of these people are part of that crowd - most of them are newer channels, and they're all socially liberal. So I don't see any of them having any reason to convert.
@PlasmaBallin Thanks for that perspective! Is there a prominent atheist or two you'd like to see added from those different camps?
@kenakofer I think there are very few YT atheists from that group that are still prominent as YT atheists. Most of them have either left YouTube or make different content now.