Which states have veto power in the UN Security Council in 2050?
➕
Plus
9
Ṁ3526
2050
97%
France
95%
United States of America
95%
People's Republic of China
95%
Great Britain
92%
Russia
25%
Any East Asian or Southeast Asian state or intergovernmental organization (excluding China)
22%
India
19%
Brazil
13%
Any arabic state or intergovernmental organization
12%
European Union
10%
Any african state or intergovernmental organization

each answer resolves YES if the country or one of its successor states has veto power in the UN Security Council sometime in the year 2050.

resolves NO otherwise.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:

As I understand it, the UN's charter doesn't have a mechanism to strip a country of its veto power, and any amendment to the charter can be vetoed. There's no incentive to relinquish veto power, thus it's a ratchet -- it will only ever move towards "more countries can veto."

I don't think there's going to be a push to grant any more countries veto power, since vetos greatly hinder the usefulness of the security council. Certainly not a "full" veto, equal in breadth and power to the P5.

I think that if there are significant changes by 2050, it will be through the formation of a new intergovernmental body that usurps the UN in relevance. The UN needn't ever go away, but there's no reason it will always be the premier organization.

That said, it's ultimately just a political tool. If one of the P5 were to become a pariah without allies in the council, then I'm sure they could be stripped of their power or kicked out. It may not be "legal" according to the charter, but a charter is just an agreement. What matters is enforcement, and if you're being kicked out, what are you going to do about it, go to war?

@DanHomerick Yes, I think its very unlikely that members lose their veto power, there may be some legal loopholes like an Emergency special session of the United Nations General Assembly. But I think they would only kick a member from the concil after another world war.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules